Jeremy W. Willett

Jeremy W. Willett

Partner

Jeremy Willett is an experienced trial and appellate lawyer, who focuses his litigation practice mainly in the area of professional liability, including the defense of physicians and lawyers. He has also worked on complex general liability and environmental cases. He has tried professional liability cases to verdict in a wide range of matters since 2007. In July 2010, Mr. Willett became a founding partner of the law firm of O’Neill McFadden & Willett LLP. Since its inception, O’Neill McFadden & Willett LLP has steadily grown in size and in the number of clients, becoming one of the most trusted law firms in Indiana.

Representative Trials and Appellate Decisions

Mr. Willett tried the following jury trials:

Cohen v. DelPriore, Hamilton Superior Court, Noblesville, Indiana, February 3 – February 7, 2025. Defense Verdict.
Anguiano v. Lee, Porter Superior Court, Valparaiso, Indiana, July 8 – July 12, 2024. Defense Verdict.
Radomille v. Miller, St. Joseph Circuit Court, South Bend, Indiana, February 2 – February 9, 2024. Defense Verdict.
Hess v. Cezar, Lake Superior Court, Gary, Indiana, September 2022. Defense Verdict.
Connell v. Mohideen, Porter Superior Court, Valparaiso, Indiana, May 15 – May 24, 2017. Defense Verdict.
Perez v. Hu, Lake Superior Court, Crown Point, Indiana, October 31 – November 4, 2016. Defense Verdict. Lane v. Mercho, Vigo Superior Court, Terre Haute, Indiana, March 31 – April 4, 2014. Defense Verdict.
Cooley v. Yoon, et al., Lake Superior Court, Crown Point, Indiana, November 18-26, 2013. Defense Verdict.
Katsaros v. Loeb, et al., Jasper Superior Court, Rensselaer, Indiana, September 23-October 2, 2013. Defense Verdict.
Dallas v. Ylagan, Porter Circuit Court, Valparaiso, Indiana, September 24-28, 2012. Defense Verdict.
Teets v. Karpik, Lake Superior Court, Crown Point, Indiana, August 30-September 2, 2011. Defense Verdict.
Estate of Jerkan v. Cortez, Lake Superior Court, Hammond, Indiana, August 9-16, 2010. Whether an emergency medicine physician’s treatment of a patient with necrotizing fasciitis was negligent. Defense Verdict.
Guenther v. Bowers, Lake Superior Court, Hammond, Indiana, February 22-March 1, 2010. Whether defendant gynecologist’s alleged failure to perform total abdominal hysterectomy resulted in a missed diagnosis of cervical cancer. Defense Verdict.
Greer v. Scott, Lake Superior Court, Hammond, Indiana, January 11-15, 2010. Whether a general surgeon and family practice doctor’s alleged failure to order DVT prophylaxis caused the decedent to develop a pulmonary embolism. Plaintiff Verdict.

Mr. Willett has also had success at the appellate court level. His reported appellate decisions include:

Miller v. Yedlowski, 916 N.E.2d 246 (Ind.Ct.App. 2009). Successfully reversed the Trial Court’s denial of defendant’s motion for summary judgment. Appellate Court instructed the Trial Court to enter summary judgment on behalf of defendant.
Blaker v. Young, 911 N.E.2d 648 (Ind.Ct.App. 2009). Successfully affirmed the Trial Court’s entry of summary judgment on behalf of the defendant.
Custer v. Wolfe, 867 N.E.2d 589 (Ind.Ct.App. 2007). Challenged jury verdict based on Plaintiff’s failure to introduce evidence of any increased risk of harm.
Wallen v. Hossler, 130 N.E.3d 138 (Ind.Ct.App. 2019). Challenged claim of multiple recoveries under Indiana’s M.M.A.

Nominations

Mr. Willett was featured as one of Indiana’s “Rising Stars” multiple times early in his career. Since then, Mr. Willett has been selected as an Indiana “Super Lawyer” in the field of medical malpractice defense on a regular basis. In 2025, Mr. Willett was awarded the Indiana Defense Lawyer of the Year by the Defense Trial Counsel of Indiana.

Professional Background

Mr. Willett is a founding member of O’Neill McFadden & Willett LLP. Prior to founding the firm, Mr. Willett practiced law at Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP, where he focused primarily on professional liability defense. Mr. Willett started his legal career as a clerk for the Honorable Judge John Pera and for the Environmental Protection Agency. He then worked at CNA Insurance and Colliau, Elenius, Murphy, Carluccio, Keener & Morrow in Chicago, Illinois.

Prior to his legal career, Mr. Willett studied abroad in Germany and Austria. He was chosen to receive an Educational Fulbright award to teach English in Vienna, Austria. In 2007, Mr. Willett was elected to the Lake Central High School Athletic Hall of Fame. Additionally, Mr. Willett was honored to become a board member of South Shore Arts which serves the community with youth outreach programs, cultural events, and funding for arts in Northwest Indiana.

Mr. Willett is a member of the Indiana Bar Association and is licensed to practice law in both state and federal courts in Indiana.

Mr. Willett resides in Crown Point, Indiana with his wife, Jennifer, and sons, Avery and Owen. His hobbies include hockey, soccer, and performing music with his band.

Attorney Profile